Insights from Caldwell’s Drew Railton
Canada’s executive talent market is being shaped by global competition, major investment in infrastructure and critical sectors, rapid advances in AI, trade uncertainty, and growing succession pressures.
In Hunt Scanlon Media’s 2026 Canada Recruiting Special Issue, Caldwell’s Drew Railton, regional managing partner, Canada, shared his perspective on what these shifts mean for Canadian organizations, where leadership talent is proving hardest to find, and what boards should consider before beginning a senior-level search.
Below are highlights from his interview and commentary.
Read the full 2026 Canada Recruiting Special Issue →
How is the talent market changing for Canadian companies?
“It has made the talent market much bigger without making local context any less important. Canada has a deep pool of accomplished executives, and for many searches the strongest candidates are right here. But Canadian companies increasingly compete for customers, capital and talent on an international stage.”
For Railton, that does not mean every Canadian search needs to become a global one.
“The advantage is flexibility: defining the market around what the business needs. Sometimes that means a predominantly Canadian search. Sometimes it means looking across North America or further afield.”
Wherever candidates come from, he says local context continues to matter, from Canada’s regulatory and governance environment to its business culture and stakeholder dynamics.
How open are Canadian boards to executives from outside the country?
“Canadian boards are open to looking outside the country, but the appetite varies considerably by mandate.”
Where government, regulation, labour relations or local stakeholder relationships are significant parts of the role, Railton says Canadian experience can carry considerable weight. Other mandates may place greater emphasis on a particular type or scale of experience.
“The key question is how much prior Canadian experience actually matters to success in the role.”
Executives entering from another market need to demonstrate that their experience will translate, that they can establish credibility with Canadian stakeholders and that they are prepared to learn the nuances of the market.
Where is leadership talent proving hardest to find?
Some of the tightest talent markets are in areas where Canada is investing heavily.
“The toughest searches right now are for leaders who have already operated at significant scale in areas where Canada is investing heavily. Major projects are a good example.”
Railton points to strong demand across infrastructure, energy, construction, defence, and critical minerals, where the pool of executives who have successfully led complex, multibillion-dollar projects can be relatively small.
AI is creating another challenge. Many executives can speak confidently about the technology. The smaller group is those who can demonstrate that they have moved beyond pilots and delivered measurable results across an organization.
“Many leaders can speak fluently about AI. Far fewer have a track record of making it work across an organization, and companies are competing hard for them.”
More broadly, highly specific search criteria can narrow the field quickly.
“The more requirements a company treats as non-negotiable, the smaller the market becomes.”
How are tariffs and trade pressures changing leadership requirements?
Railton is seeing the impact vary significantly by sector and region. Manufacturing and steel have been hit particularly hard, while construction continues to see hiring activity alongside higher input costs. Demand also remains strong across energy, infrastructure, defence and critical minerals.
At the senior-most levels, trade issues are increasingly part of the leadership mandate itself.
“Trade and supply chain knowledge are increasingly expected at the CEO and CFO level. These issues have become too important to push down to a VP and leave there.”
Government relations and scenario planning are also becoming more important as organizations navigate policy changes, shifting project economics and multiple possible outcomes.
Communication matters too, particularly where economic uncertainty affects employees and communities.
“In communities where employees worry about layoffs, plant closures, or the future of a major local employer, leaders who go quiet lose the room.”
Is succession planning becoming more urgent?
“Succession planning is getting more attention, particularly at the board level, but its quality and depth still vary considerably.”
Many organizations can identify potential internal successors. Fewer have a clear view of who could assume the role immediately, who might be ready several years from now, and what development each person would need along the way.
“Retirements are adding urgency. They are bringing some transitions forward sooner than expected, which can quickly expose gaps when no internal successor is ready.”
Railton encourages boards to benchmark internal talent against the external market early. Doing so gives organizations more time to develop leaders and make deliberate decisions before a vacancy becomes urgent.
How should Canadian organizations approach executive compensation?
“Compensation has become a bigger part of search strategy because, for many senior roles, the talent market is now North American and sometimes global.”
Candidates increasingly compare opportunities across borders, including cash compensation, equity, benefits, taxation, flexibility and long-term financial upside. But compensation is only one part of the decision.
Strong candidates also weigh the mandate, the quality of the board and management team, their authority to make decisions and what success in the role could mean for their career.
“But compensation still has to be credible.”
The key, Railton says, is calibrating the compensation framework early enough that a significant gap does not emerge after a company has invested considerable time in a candidate.
What can derail a senior-level search?
One of the most common problems occurs before the market is ever approached.
“The most common one is starting the search before the decision-makers are aligned on the mandate.”
If the board, CEO, and other stakeholders have different ideas about what success looks like, the candidate profile can shift throughout the process.
Railton also cautions against over-specifying the resume. A long list of mandatory experiences can appear rigorous while unnecessarily narrowing the talent market.
Companies also need to be candid about the opportunity.
“Strong candidates should understand the hard parts of the mandate, the stakeholder dynamics and the expectations they’re walking into. Overselling may spark interest, but it creates problems later.”
And throughout the process, the candidate is evaluating the organization as closely as the organization is evaluating the candidate.
“Slow decisions, mixed messages and unclear compensation can cost a company a strong candidate.”
Drew Railton is Caldwell’s regional managing partner, Canada. He has more than 20 years of experience placing senior executives and board directors and advises clients on board, CEO and senior executive recruitment.
Drew’s comments appeared in Hunt Scanlon Media’s 2026 Canada Recruiting Special Issue.